Intended for healthcare professionals

Who should decide? Qualitative analysis of panel data from public, patients, healthcare professionals, and insurers on priorities in health care

Karien Stronks, Anne-Margreet Strijbis, Johannes F Wendte, Louise J Gunning-Schepers
Table 1

Services included in list and summary of the information given to panel members

ServiceSummary of background information given*Costs (in million Dutch guilders)No of people affected
Home careNature of care (mostly household support, care was only small part)1740About 7.5% of households
Age distribution of clients (mostly elderly people)
Copayments
Waiting lists
Circumcision for menReasons for circumcision (about 60% of cost for religious reasons, rest of costs: medical)10About 9000 circumcisions a year
Providers: general practitioner, hospital (former much cheaper), and traditional doctors
Homes for the elderlyCopayments (costs of living paid by inhabitants themselves)3185About 6% of population >65 years
Future demographic developments
Homoeopathic medicinesEffectivity (effectiveness not proved yet)40Many (exact number unknown)
Comparison with total costs of medicines (only 1% of total costs)
Screening for breast cancerEpidemiological data (incidence, etc)45Women aged 50-70 years (around 400 000)
Scientific basis of current programme (cost effectiveness study; number of life years gained)
Lung transplantationCharacterisation of patients in need of transplantation6About 20 transplantations a year
Waiting lists (limited number of transplant lungs)
Cost per transplantation, follow up included (about 300 000 Dutch guilders)
Travel allowancesNature of service (allowance of costs made in order to travel to healthcare services)17212% Of insured population
Copayments
Future developments (higher costs because of demographic developments, etc)
Oral contraceptivesNature of service (effective, risks almost nil)145About 35% of women aged 16-50 years
Price for individual (maximum 100 guilders year)
In vitro fertilisationEffectivity (similar to “natural” pregnancies but more complications)15About 5500 treatments a year
Restrictions (maximum of 3 treatments publicly funded)
Costs per treatment
Treatment of sport injuriesCharacter of treatments (which sorts)2802.7 Million accidents a year
Nature of costs: costs of medical care
  • *Selective information only; information panels received was more extensive.

  • †Refers to publicly funded costs (in 1993), copayments excluded (around 3 Dutch guilders=£1($1.6)).