Education and debate

Why should women have lower reference limits for haemoglobin and ferritin concentrations than men?

D Hugh Rushton, honorary senior lecturer ^a, Robin Dover, clinical research officer ^b, Anthony W Sainsbury, senior veterinary officer ^c, Michael J Norris, senior lecturer ^a, Jeremy J H Gilkes, consultant dermatologist ^d, Ian D Ramsay, consultant endocrinologist ^d. 

^a School of Pharmacy and Biomedical Sciences, University of Portsmouth, Portsmouth PO1 2DT, ^b Imperial Cancer Research Fund, Lincoln's Inn Field, London WC2A 3PX, ^c Institute of Zoology, Zoological Society of London, Regents Park, London NW1 4RY, ^d Lister Hospital, London SW1W 8RH

Correspondence to: D Hugh Rushton rushton{at}btinternet.com

The need to transport oxygen and remove carbon dioxide from animal tissue is a fundamental requirement of life, independent of age or sex.¹ The role of iron in humans and many other mammals is central to this process. ^{2 3} Haemoglobin concentration and red blood cell count are important diagnostic indicators for anaemia in humans and animals.

In prepubertal humans no major differences can be found between the sexes in red blood cell count or haemoglobin and serum ferritin concentrations.⁴ Only after the onset of menstruation does a difference emerge.⁴ Not until 10 years after the menopause does this situation revert in women, when the haemoglobin concentration becomes similar to that of aged matched men. ^{4 5} This situation is compounded by the fact that modern women have a different reproductive history from those in the past. They reach sexual maturity at an earlier age, have fewer pregnancies, and breast feed for shorter periods; as such they menstruate for more years than women in the past. Menstruation is the principal cause of iron loss in women.^6-8 Furthermore, 90% of UK females of childbearing age do not achieve the recommended daily intake of elemental iron (14.8 mg) from their diet.⁹ Evaluation of the haemoglobin concentration and red blood cell count of women from Canada, Central America, China, and the United States shows that this situation is widespread. ^{4 10-14} Women worldwide are at risk of being in a negative iron balance, and by current criteria if their haemoglobin concentration is less than 115 g/l they are deemed to be anaemic, whereas in men the cut-off point is 130 g/l.¹⁵

As far as the authors are aware, of the primates only humans show a sex difference in haemoglobin concentration and red blood cell count. A survey of the haematology of mammals also failed to establish a difference.¹⁶ Whereas most mammals, including the New World primates, do not menstruate, the Old World primates, which includes the apes, do. As with humans, Old World primates have premenses, breeding, and menopausal phases, and the frequency of menstruation is similar to humans, with a menses around every 28 days.^16-18 Unlike humans, however, no significant difference was found between the lower haemoglobin concentration (table) or red blood cell count (data not presented) of female primates and aged matched males sampled by the Zoological Society of London.¹⁷

Haem synthesis occurs largely in the mitochondria.¹² There is no evidence showing either a reduction in mitochondrial number or a reduced ability for haem synthesis in women of childbearing age than in men. It might therefore be argued that the hormonal environment is a possible cause for the observed sex difference in red blood cell count and haemoglobin and serum ferritin concentrations in humans. Increased serum erythropoietin concentrations occur in response to anaemia, which in turn increases iron absorption from the diet. Hallberg et al have shown that men and women of the same iron status absorb the same amounts of iron from the same diet.¹⁹ If they are correct then there should be no difference in the erythropoietin concentrations of men and women with "normal" serum ferritin concentrations matched for age and weight. Similarly no sex difference can be found for thyroxine; therefore, with the exception of iron and the sex hormones there is no evidence of lower concentrations for any other parameter involved in haem synthesis in women of childbearing age than there is in men.²⁰ Further, the data from menstruating Old World primates suggest that a difference in sex hormones is unlikely to be responsible for the sex difference in humans. Consequently, of all the parameters involved, iron is the only one with a measured difference.

The mean upper limit for haemoglobin concentration in primates that menstruate is significantly higher in males than it is in females, similar to humans. However, this is not the case in primates that do not menstruate (table), suggesting that menses is responsible for limiting the upper haemoglobin concentration in non-human primates that menstruate.¹⁷ Perhaps the same may be true of humans, with an iron deficient diet significantly influencing the lower haemoglobin concentration in women.

No evidence supports a view that women of reproductive age have a lower biological requirement for any haem parameters than do aged matched men. The data from humans point to the possibility that the current lower reference levels for red blood cell count and haemoglobin and serum ferritin concentrations in women have been derived from sampling populations that are deficient in iron. Consequently, it would seem that a large number of women spend a major part of their lives with a negative iron balance arising from a dietary imbalance. Iron deficiency is the most important nutritional problem affecting humans around the world.²¹ The presence of haem iron in the diet of humans enhances the absorption of non-haem iron, and the trend towards diets with a lower haem iron content may add to the problem of dietary insufficiency.²² In addition, the typical UK diet contains many common products that can limit iron absorptionfor example, dairy produce, cereals, and tannin²¹thereby compounding the situation.

The deleterious effects of iron deficiency and iron deficient anaemia are due partly to impaired delivery of oxygen to the tissues and partly to a deficiency of iron containing compounds, especially enzymes, in various tissues.² Restlessness and irritability in children who are deficient in iron has been related to increased concentrations of catecholamines, which return to normal after treatment with iron.²² Lower IQ scores have been found in UK and American adolescent girls who are deficient in iron. ^{23 24} Abnormalities in response to infection have been shown in people who are deficient in iron, where decreased neutrophil function and impaired T cell proliferation occurs.³ Studies in humans have confirmed the findings from animals of reduced work capacity and poor work performance in iron deficient anaemia.²⁵ Reduced thermoregulation has also been confirmed in people who are iron deficient where norepinephrine concentration was increased, and differences were found in concentrations of epinephrine, dopamine, triiodothyronine, and thyroxine. Normal concentrations for these parameters were restored after iron supplementation.²⁵ Hair loss has been reported in women with iron deficiency, which responded to iron supplementation. ^{26 27} The quantity of non-haem iron in the brain is to a large extent independent of the iron stores in the body.²⁰ Overall, 10% of the iron complement of the adult brain is present at birth, and by the age of 10 this has reached 50%; however, not until the early 20s is the full adult complement achieved.²² Although most of the deleterious effects of iron deficiency can be reversed by appropriate iron supplementation, of concern is the possibility that if during the adolescent years a shortfall exists, then, as in rats, humans may not be able to make up the deficiency by iron supplementation, and adolescent girls may enter adult life with a compromised complement of iron in the brain.^20-25

We propose that the current "normal" values for red blood cell count and haemoglobin and serum ferritin concentration cited by laboratories were obtained from sampling populations that contained a large proportion of women with iron deficiency. We suggest using reference ranges for men for these parameters when assessing the haematological and iron status of women. By current criteria, iron deficiency is the commonest cause of anaemia in the world, with more than half a billion people experiencing adverse effects.²⁸ If this hypothesis is accepted then noticeably more women will be classified as being iron deficient or anaemic. Reclassification of red blood cell count and haemoglobin and serum ferritin concentrations to normal values for men would be expected to have fundamental and positive implications for women's health and welfare.

Acknowledgments

We thank Professor Hideo Uno, Dr Julian Barth and Dr Chris Gummer, Peter Cundall, and Nina Busuttil for their help, comments, and suggestions concerning the manuscript.

Contributors: DHR had the original idea for this paper and initiated the debate with RD and MJN. JJHG and IDR provided the medical opinions and AWS collected the primate data and presented the veterinary views. The authors jointly wrote the paper, and DHR analysed the primate data. DHR will act as guarantor for the paper.

Footnotes

Competing interests: None declared.

References

1.	Bothwell TH, Charlton RW, Cook JD, Finch CA. Iron metabolism in man. Oxford: Blackwell Scientific, 1979:7-43.
2.	Hallberg L. Iron absorption and iron deficiency. Human nutrition. Clin Nutr 1982; 36C: 259-278.
3.	Dallman PR. Biochemical basis for the manifestations of iron deficiency. Ann Rev Nutr 1986; 6: 13-40[CrossRef][Medline].
4.	Valberg LS, Sorbie J, Ludwig J, Pelletier O. Serum ferritin and the iron status of Canadians. Can Med Assoc J 1976; 114: 417-421[Abstract].
5.	Myers AM, Saunders CRG, Chalmers DG. The haemoglobin level of fit elderly people. Lancet 1968; iiAug 3: 261-263[CrossRef].
6.	Hallberg L, Hogdahl AM, Nilsson L, Rybo G. Menstrual blood lossa population study. Variation at different ages and attempts to define normality Acta Obstet Gynec Scand 1966; 45: 320-351[Medline].
7.	Frassinelli-Gunderson EP, Margen S, Brown JR. Iron stores in users of oral contraceptive agents. Am J Clin Nutr 1985; 41: 703-712[Abstract/Free Full Text].
8.	Simon TL, Garry PJ, Hooper EM. Iron stores in blood donors. JAMA 1981; 245: 2038-2043[Abstract].
9.	Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. The dietary and nutritional survey of British adultsfurther analysis. London: HMSO, 1994:72-75.
10.	Viteri FE, de Tuna V, Guzman MA. Normal haematological values in the Central American population. Br J Haematol 1972; 23: 189-204[Medline].
11.	Ji G, Su Z, Bo-ling S, Hui-min F, Li-hui H. Menstrual blood loss and hematologic indices in healthy Chinese women. J Reprod Med 1987; 32: 822-826[Medline].
12.	Looker AC, Dallman PR, Carroll MD, Gunter EW, Johnson CL. Prevalence of iron deficiency in the United States. JAMA 1997; 277: 973-976[Abstract].
13.	Cook JD, Finch CA, Smith N. Evaluation of the iron status of a population. Blood 1976; 48: 449-455[Abstract/Free Full Text].
14.	Cook JD, Skikne BS, Lynch SR, Reusser ME. Estimates of iron sufficiency in the US population. Blood 1986; 68: 726-731[Abstract/Free Full Text].
15.	Hoffbrand AV, Pettit JE. Essential haematology 3rd ed. Oxford: Blackwell Scientific, 1993:419.
16.	Jain NC, Jain AH. Essentials of veterinary hematology. Philadelphia: Lea and Febiger, 1993.
17.	Lynx. Haematological and biochemical data base. London: Zoological Society, Jan, 2000.
18.	Walker ML. Menopause in female rhesus monkeys. Am J Primatol 1995; 35: 59-71.
19.	Hallberg L, Hultén L, Gramatkovski E. Iron absorption from the whole diet in men: how effective is the regulation of iron absoption? J Clin Nutr 1997; 66: 347-356.
20.	Hallgren B, Sourander P. The effect of age on the non-haemin iron in the human brain. J Neurochem 1958; 3: 41-51[CrossRef][Medline].
21.	Hallberg L, Sandström B, Aggett PJ. Iron, zinc and other trace elements. In: Garrow SJ, James WPT, eds. Human nutrition and dietetics, 9th ed. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone, 1993.
22.	Dillmann E, Johnson DG, Martin J, Mackler B, Finch CA. Catecholamine elevation in iron deficiency. Am J Physiol 1979; 237: 337-81R.
23.	Nelson M. Iron status and cognitive function in UK adolescent girls; an intervention study. In: First report from the House of Commons Education and Employment Committee. School meals. London: Stationery Office, 1999. (HC 96.)
24.	Bruner AB, Joffe G, Duggan AK, Casella JF, Brandt J. Randomised study of cognitive effects of iron supplementation in non-anaemic iron deficient adolescent girls. Lancet 1996; 348: 992-996[CrossRef][Medline].
25.	Srrimshaw NS. Functional consequences of iron deficiency in human populations [review]. J Nutr Sci Vitamonol 1984; 30: 47-83.
26.	Hård S. Non-anemic iron deficiency as an etiological factor in diffuse loss of hair of the scalp in women. Acta Derm Venereo 1963; 43: 562-569[Medline].
27.	Rushton DH, Ramsay ID. The importance of adequate serum ferritin levels during oral cyproterone acetate and ethinyl oestradiol treatment of diffuse androgen-dependent alopecia in women. Clin Endocrinol 1992; 36: 421-427[Medline].
28.	Andrews NC. Medical progress: disorders of iron metabolism. N Engl J Med 1999; 341: 1986-1995[Free Full Text].

(Accepted 20 February 2001)