Rapid Responses to:
|
|
Rapid Responses: Rapid Responses published:
-
![[Read Rapid Response]](/icons/misc/sectionDOWN.gif)
The other side of the Palastinian tragedy
- Michael L. Loren (15 October 2004)
-
Palestine: "war crimes"
- Kenneth Lancer, Radlett Lane Shenley Herts WD7 9JP (15 October 2004)
-
The truth is not so one-sided
- William L Jackson (15 October 2004)
-
Palestine: the assault on health and other war crimes
- Giovanni David Zoanetti (15 October 2004)
-
BMA should campaign on Palestine
- Peter M Neville (16 October 2004)
-
The truth hurts
- Ali Riza (16 October 2004)
-
Obedience to international law
- Mark Struthers (16 October 2004)
-
Palestine: teh assault on health and other war crimes
- Ahmed Alsaidi (17 October 2004)
-
Unbalanced
- Gerald M. Fraser (17 October 2004)
-
Misuse of the columns of the BMJ
- Joy Wolfe (17 October 2004)
-
Palestinians
- Alan Ferris (17 October 2004)
-
Palestine
- Raymond Million (17 October 2004)
-
BMJ: Summerfield's fictions and agenda of hatred
- Gerald M. Steinberg (17 October 2004)
-
BMA - Palestine and Israel
- Saul W. Issroff (17 October 2004)
-
Exploiting medicine for terrorism
- Dr Robin J Stamler (17 October 2004)
-
Propaganda?
- Nigel Bowness (17 October 2004)
-
Summerfield's misplaced outrage
- Irwin J Mansdorf (17 October 2004)
-
It's True
- Ahmed Nasser (17 October 2004)
-
Shame on BMJ
- David Lewis (18 October 2004)
-
More Summerfield rantings
- Daniel Y Ellis (18 October 2004)
-
Palestinian Violations of Medical Neutrality
- Steven M Albert (18 October 2004)
-
Israel, Palestine and the BMJ
- Daniel C. Hurwitz (18 October 2004)
-
My personal view!
- Alexander J Lustman (18 October 2004)
-
the credibility of the bmj
- charles j simenoff (18 October 2004)
-
islamic guidelines for war.
- manan vasenwala (18 October 2004)
-
"Servile" BMA
- John Marks (18 October 2004)
-
Limits of Free Speech and BMJ Policy
- Jay Ilangaratne (18 October 2004)
-
Re: Obeying international law: an addendum to Armageddon
- Mark Struthers (18 October 2004)
-
An appeal for balance on the issue of Israel/Palestine
- Michael E Coren (18 October 2004)
-
What good is the BMJ doing?
- Kalman M Kafetz (18 October 2004)
-
Misuse of a professional Journal
- Jeffrey S Hillman (18 October 2004)
-
A gratuitous swipe
- David B Landau (18 October 2004)
-
Why stick with Middle Eastern politics?
- Ellen Goudsmit (18 October 2004)
-
Equipoise
- Steven Ford (18 October 2004)
-
Half the truth is still a lie
- Barry M Miller (18 October 2004)
-
Re: Why stick with Middle Eastern politics?
- Mark Struthers (18 October 2004)
-
More heat than light
- Tom Marshall (18 October 2004)
-
Response to Derek Summerfield’s Personal View
- Simon AP Jenkins (18 October 2004)
-
Propaganda
- Dr Russell D Gilmore (18 October 2004)
-
What was the BMJ thinking of?
- Alastair M. Santhouse (19 October 2004)
-
Re: Obedience to international law
- Jacob C Lax (19 October 2004)
-
Propaganda Like This Kills, Doctor
- Naomi Ragen (19 October 2004)
-
Consistent standards
- A. Michael Denman (19 October 2004)
-
Palestine ---
- Jerome S Sallo PhD (19 October 2004)
-
Blatant misuse of the power of the press
- Yigal Samocha, Dallas TX 75062 (19 October 2004)
-
Palestine distorted
- Brendan M Schulman (19 October 2004)
-
Bias in Dr Summerfields article
- Judith A Tobin (19 October 2004)
-
Re: Obedience to international law
- Leonard Klahr (19 October 2004)
-
D> Summerfield: Palestine.......
- David Gershon (19 October 2004)
-
Re: Obedience to international law
- Patricia Williams (19 October 2004)
-
Palestinian Disregard for Their Own People
- Martin Epstein (19 October 2004)
-
Anti-Semitism
- steven a sass (19 October 2004)
-
The foolish judge
- Robert M. Wolfe (19 October 2004)
-
Identification or Counter-transference?
- Perry B. Bach (19 October 2004)
-
Articles like this put the entire BMJ in trouble
- Dan A. Pankowsky (19 October 2004)
-
The Numbers Game
- Stephen A Berger (19 October 2004)
-
Agitprop
- Fred Garcia (19 October 2004)
-
The bias of a crossection analisys
- Miguel Gus (19 October 2004)
-
The British MEDICAL Journal??
- Gari Blumberg (19 October 2004)
-
science or polemics?
- Lester Sireling (19 October 2004)
-
Biased Account
- Linda M. Stock (19 October 2004)
-
Misuse of the columns of the BMJ
- Claire A Samuel, Julian H Barth (19 October 2004)
-
Just Wanted To Add Something
- Michael Levin (19 October 2004)
-
New low for the BMJ and Summerfield
- M Finch (19 October 2004)
-
Not Again!
- Dean J Noimark (19 October 2004)
-
Fact, fiction, fantasy and fanaticism
- Arnold zermansky (19 October 2004)
-
Academic journal not the place for inciteful ranting
- Bernard Freudenthal (19 October 2004)
-
the real medical care israel gives to the palestinians
- charles j simenoff (19 October 2004)
-
Israel has the right to protect its citizens.
- Jacob Amir, M.D. (19 October 2004)
-
Dr Derek Summerfield's Article on Palestine
- Zarina Bhatia (19 October 2004)
-
BMJ: Summerfield's article - sins of omission and comission
- Liz Lightstone (19 October 2004)
-
BMJ shamed by media watchdog...
- David M Lewis (19 October 2004)
-
Dr. Derek Summerfield's Views
- David Ronis (19 October 2004)
-
Well done
- Miriam M. Reik (19 October 2004)
-
Palestine
- Carol B Gould (19 October 2004)
-
Get Your Facts Straight
- Steven B Perlmutter (19 October 2004)
-
Shame!
- Bruce I. Goderez, M.D. (19 October 2004)
-
Is the BMJ a Palestinian propaganda mouthpiece?
- Bobby Timbo (19 October 2004)
-
Disturbing
- Michael L. Zager (19 October 2004)
-
Inappropriate paper
- Peter S Teitelbaum (19 October 2004)
-
Editor should resign
- Yaakov Nahmias (19 October 2004)
-
Reporting human rights abuses
- Lewis A McLean (19 October 2004)
-
Pulp Fiction
- Elliot D Sorene (19 October 2004)
-
Peace process
- Dr John Rumbold (19 October 2004)
-
Re: Obedience to international law
- Julius Hollander (19 October 2004)
-
Re: Obedience to international law
- Henry Clinton-Davis (19 October 2004)
-
Betrayal of principle
- Michael Schachter (19 October 2004)
-
Let the truth be told
- George R. Alexander (19 October 2004)
-
Crude Israel Bashing
- Alain E. SPORTICHE (19 October 2004)
-
Confused
- Rachel Idgar (19 October 2004)
-
Palestine - Health
- John Goldman (19 October 2004)
-
How has this been accepted?
- Saul Kaufman (19 October 2004)
-
Pernicious Polemic
- Michael J Ingram (19 October 2004)
-
Re: Well done
- Ellen Goudsmit (19 October 2004)
-
Important issues of child health
- Adrian R Crofton (19 October 2004)
-
Medical Misdiagnosis
- Daniel Cukier (19 October 2004)
-
biased, unscientific and unfit for the BMJ
- Jonathan D Picker (19 October 2004)
-
Editorial judgement
- Alan Rubin (19 October 2004)
-
Medical ethics in Israel
- Martin Birnstingl (19 October 2004)
-
BMJ loses credibility
- Joshua D. Lenchus (19 October 2004)
-
Mis-information and Mis-use of the BMJ
- Anthony J Nicholls (19 October 2004)
-
Apology Please!
- Jeffrey Dyas (19 October 2004)
-
Derek Summerfields political views
- Antony L Richards (19 October 2004)
-
Inconsistencies show bias
- Wayne R Kaufman (19 October 2004)
-
Shameful !
- Roger T. Gregory (19 October 2004)
-
Clearly, none of the angry responses are from anyone who has actually lived in the Occupied Territories
- Nigel M Parry (19 October 2004)
-
One-sided
- Vijay Khan (19 October 2004)
-
Propoganda
- Eric M. Siegal (19 October 2004)
-
Bravo Respondents
- C.R. Schiloni (19 October 2004)
-
Summerfield article
- James H Stein, MD (19 October 2004)
-
Re: Response to Derek Summerfield’s Personal View
- Joseph McEvoy (19 October 2004)
-
Abuse and degradation of the Palestinians
- David Ben-Joseph (19 October 2004)
-
An Assault on Truth, Morality and Human Dignity
- Andrew M Tunick (19 October 2004)
-
Absolute Lies
- Michael L. Duncan, Derek Summerfield (19 October 2004)
-
Pure Propaganda
- Joseph Berman (19 October 2004)
-
Israel - bashing
- kenny livingstone (19 October 2004)
-
Palestine: An assault on itself
- Jerome Parness (19 October 2004)
-
Re: The truth hurts
- Michael Mansoor (19 October 2004)
-
Re: Obedience to international law
- Michael Mansoor (19 October 2004)
-
Incorrect, Insulting and Offensive
- Jonathan M Behar (20 October 2004)
-
NEWS ALERT: BMJ readers hijacked
- James DiPoce (20 October 2004)
-
Shame on BMJ
- Alexander Avidan (20 October 2004)
-
BMJ Shame's Itself
- Izak Paul (20 October 2004)
-
Israel Advances Palestinian Health
- Michael Ordman (20 October 2004)
-
Biased and inappropriate
- Saul I Ship (20 October 2004)
-
Health in Palestine
- Joav Merrick (20 October 2004)
-
THINK
- imraan umar (20 October 2004)
-
Re: Re: The truth hurts
- Nigel M Parry (20 October 2004)
-
Well Done BMJ
- Emma M Henney (20 October 2004)
-
Re: Re: Well done: American values lead nowhere
- Mark Struthers (20 October 2004)
-
One very distorted article
- Marc D Wittenberg (20 October 2004)
-
Re: Palestine
- Jeffrey Kohn (20 October 2004)
-
Unbalanced?
- John Geaney (20 October 2004)
-
War – The Incurable Disease of Men
- Ishay Lev (20 October 2004)
-
Welcome to the 1930s
- Terence J Davis (20 October 2004)
-
The Health of the Middle East
- Daniel Schwartz (20 October 2004)
-
Questioning the credibility of information.
- M Davis (20 October 2004)
-
Lack of objectivity
- Simon Barnard (20 October 2004)
-
Israel Wrongly Accused of the Moribund State of Palestinians
- Mark D. Bernhard,D.O. (20 October 2004)
-
The Balanced Story
- Amar M Wahid (20 October 2004)
-
There is State terrrorism too!
- Osman Ahmed (20 October 2004)
-
Damaging the good name of the BMJ
- Ian S Solomon (20 October 2004)
-
Re: Clearly, none of the angry responses are from anyone who has actually lived in the Occupied Territories
- David Ben-Joseph (20 October 2004)
-
Well presented facts!
- Abraham Moses (20 October 2004)
-
response to derek sommerville's personal view
- Simon AP Jenkins (20 October 2004)
-
re: the article by D Summerfield
- Stephen Neidle (20 October 2004)
-
Let Them Drink Bile . . .
- Joseph . C . Obi (20 October 2004)
-
Palestine
- Zahid Ghufoor (20 October 2004)
-
No competing interests ?
- Adrian S. Blaj (20 October 2004)
-
Editorial Ineptitude
- Kenneth H Levere, Nigel de Kare-Silver (20 October 2004)
-
the first step in treating a disease, is acknowledging it exists.
- Dr Suhail Hussain (20 October 2004)
-
No doubt
- Jack S. Cohen (20 October 2004)
-
What more can one say?
- A. Mark Clarfield (20 October 2004)
-
the power of the lobby
- mohammad tahir (20 October 2004)
-
Evidence based opinion
- Juliet R Cohen (20 October 2004)
-
Apartheid Israel
- Anthony Cox (20 October 2004)
-
Destruction of Medical Infrastructure/ Unbiased Links
- Mohammed Chaudry (20 October 2004)
-
It needed to be said
- Bilal M Patel (20 October 2004)
-
A new Berlin wall?
- Charles Soper (20 October 2004)
-
Health care in Palestine
- Alan F Meyers (20 October 2004)
-
When political fervour replaces scientific thought
- Aaron D Schimmer (20 October 2004)
-
Should a respected medical journal publish political diatribe?
- Laurence B Lovat (20 October 2004)
-
Re: NEWS ALERT: BMJ Readers Hijacked and Misinformed
- Doris L. DiPoce (20 October 2004)
-
Amateur Hour
- Malcolm K. Brenner (20 October 2004)
-
Congratulations to the BMJ
- Paul J Malin (20 October 2004)
-
Re: Incorrect, Insulting and Offensive
- hana berkshire (20 October 2004)
-
Soldiers are not authorised to shoot children
- Arlene Goldman (20 October 2004)
-
Publication in triplicate
- Ian N Ross (20 October 2004)
-
The article was correct
- Benjamin Kaufman (20 October 2004)
-
Personal Views in the BMJ
- Elsharkawy Ahmed (20 October 2004)
-
One sided and unhelpful
- Mark Berelowitz (20 October 2004)
-
Congratulations
- Nizar Merali (20 October 2004)
-
What Next?
- Peter N Kovachev (20 October 2004)
-
Follow the example of Boris Johnson
- Martin L. Kolinsky (20 October 2004)
-
BMJ Credibility on the line
- David J. Mitchell (20 October 2004)
-
THE TRUTH &NOTHING ELSE EXCEPT THE TRUTH
- Abdulrahman Alswaid (20 October 2004)
-
State-sponsored terrorism against Palestinians!
- Iyad Rabbani (20 October 2004)
-
The reputation of the BMJ
- Philip Lempert (20 October 2004)
-
Re: Obedience to international law
- Joel S. Keller (20 October 2004)
-
Congratulations!
- Prof. I Hussain Hussain (21 October 2004)
-
breeding the terrorist
- abdul razif (21 October 2004)
-
Partial vision
- Patrick J Bower (21 October 2004)
-
State terroism against Palestinian by Israel
- Kan Chandradeva (21 October 2004)
-
An American Pediatricians View
- Jonathan D. Reich (21 October 2004)
-
Truth Hurts
- Mustafa Iqbal (21 October 2004)
-
no hope
- Jonathan D Picker (21 October 2004)
-
Congratulations
- Dr Ummu Ainul Mokhtar (21 October 2004)
-
Reporting the consequences of Israel's Occupation
- Rand U. Carter (21 October 2004)
-
Freedom of speech
- Adnan R. SIDDIQUI (21 October 2004)
-
Shame on the BMA
- Mark Katz (21 October 2004)
-
Palestinian under occupation
- Dr. Samir Qouta, Qouta S. (21 October 2004)
-
Palestine: The assault on health and other war crimes
- Maha Kamal Hassan (21 October 2004)
-
Some comments on the responses
- M. Grant (21 October 2004)
-
We can not afford to ignore the proplems faced by the Palestinian people! Well done BMJ
- Diba Salam (21 October 2004)
-
Congratulations
- Salah Abdel Shafi (21 October 2004)
-
Please address specifics
- Steven M Rhodes (21 October 2004)
-
WHAT IS SEMITISM?
- Abdul Salim (21 October 2004)
-
anti-Israel lobby
- Nathan Hasson (21 October 2004)
-
Thank-You
- A B Haji (21 October 2004)
-
Respectful proposal
- Adrian S. Blaj (21 October 2004)
-
Lord Ha Ha?
- Wayne Jaffe (21 October 2004)
-
Balance
- Michael Schachter (21 October 2004)
-
The need for response
- Eric P. Simkin (21 October 2004)
-
Good Lord!
- Adrian S. Blaj (21 October 2004)
-
Propaganda
- Jeffrey Oppenheim (21 October 2004)
-
gross misrepresentation of facts
- Reuben E. Gross, PhD (21 October 2004)
-
Palestine: the assault on health and other war crimes
- Mr. Menahem Dunsky, Montreal H4W 3J4 (21 October 2004)
-
Personal Ignorance
- Daniel Youngerwood (21 October 2004)
-
Israel and Medical Research
- Adam Neumann (21 October 2004)
-
Inappropriate and useless waste of BMJ
- Louis Pinkett (21 October 2004)
-
Emesis
- S. M. Roth (21 October 2004)
-
60 Years Ago
- Aviezri S Fraenkel (21 October 2004)
-
SUMMERFIELDS BRAVERY- Speaking the truth and inflaming the Jewish Lobby
- A SAEED (21 October 2004)
-
You cannot hide the truth!
- Yousef Bazian (21 October 2004)
-
Palestine: the assault on health and other war crimes
- Derek Summerfield (21 October 2004)
-
Palestine: the assault on health and other war crimes
- Zak A JABBAR (21 October 2004)
-
Shame
- Dr. Tasmina A Goraya (21 October 2004)
-
It is about time to describe reality.
- Safwan Badr (21 October 2004)
-
attitude to death
- harvey gordon (21 October 2004)
-
A HOPELESS SITUATION
- John Stone (21 October 2004)
-
The need to see the "OTHER SIDE"
- Osman Ahmed (21 October 2004)
-
Learn to accept the truth
- Siraj Malakai (21 October 2004)
-
In complete agreement with Kenneth Lancer
- Andrzej Lozowski (21 October 2004)
-
Christian Aid Backs Up Derek Summerfield
- Taalib Shamsuddin (21 October 2004)
-
the assault on health in palestine
- raymond m deane (21 October 2004)
-
Re: Palestine: the assault on health and other war crimes
- Mona Baker (21 October 2004)
-
The Tragedy that is Palestine.
- James C. Davidson (22 October 2004)
-
Re: Israel and Medical Research
- Ruth Hutt (22 October 2004)
-
Let us now move on
- Simon AP Jenkins (22 October 2004)
-
Dr. Summerfield's Moral Courage to Speak Out
- Omar S. Barghouti (22 October 2004)
-
Totally correct and justified
- Brian Robinson (22 October 2004)
-
The Palestinians are not totally innocent
- Robert Eichel (22 October 2004)
-
Re: Re: Palestine: the assault on health and other war crimes
- Anthony Cox (22 October 2004)
-
Re: Re: Clearly, none of the angry responses are from anyone who has actually lived in the Occupied Territories
- Nigel M Parry (22 October 2004)
-
Biased does not begin to describe it
- Jiri Adler (22 October 2004)
-
Palestine: the assault on health and other war crimes
- Ateeq Hussan (22 October 2004)
-
End the Occupation
- Helga A Baumgarten (22 October 2004)
-
Psychosis attributes of a child palestinian suicide bomber
- Esther Richman (22 October 2004)
-
The Case for Israel
- Daniel Goldstein (22 October 2004)
-
Re: Obeying international law: Messrs Klahr, Keller and Hollander
- Mark Struthers (22 October 2004)
-
Peace and Justice Go Hand In Hand
- Walayat Hussain (22 October 2004)
-
The truth please
- Farouk Tootla (22 October 2004)
-
Editor, where are you?
- Mark Berelowitz (22 October 2004)